With all the major sources having unveiled their Brewers’ top prospect lists already, I figured it high time we had a little discussion on the topic here. There are three publications which I read regarding prospects which I think are pretty good sources: (1) Baseball America – known for valuing physical skills, tools and potential well over performance, (2) Baseball Prospectus – known for valuing performance equally with physical tools and other factors, and (3) John Sickels’ Minor League Ball site – which blends elements of (1) and (2). Here’s how the three sites ranked the Brewers’ farmhands:
Baseball America Top-101. Matt LaPorta, of
2. Manny Parra, lhp
3. Alcides Escobar, ss
4. Jeremy Jeffress, rhp
5. Cole Gillespie, of
6. Mat Gamel, 3b
7. Brent Brewer, ss
8. Angel Salome, c
9. Lorenzo Cain, of
10. Caleb Gindl, of
Baseball ProspectusFive-Star Prospects
1. Matt LaPorta, LF
2. Manny Parra, LHP
Four-Star Prospects
3. Jeremy Jeffress, RHP
Three-Star Prospects
4. Cole Gillespie, OF
5. Angel Salome, C
6. Alcides Escobar, SS
7. Mat Gamel, 3B
8. Caleb Gindl, OF
9. Luis Pena, RHP
10. Robert Bryson, RHP
11. Brent Brewer, SS
John Sickels1. Matt LaPorta, OF, Grade B+ (great bat, glove??)
2. Manny Parra, LHP, Grade B+ (a really good prospect who needs more attention)
3. Mat Gamel, 3B, Grade B
4. Jeremy Jeffress, RHP, Grade B (assumes he stops smoking dope)
5. Jonathan Lucroy, C, Grade B-
6. Taylor Green, 3B, Grade B-
7. Cole Gillespie, OF, Grade C+
8. Alicides Escobar, SS, Grade C+ (overrated by lots of people IMHO)
9. Caleb Gindl, OF, Grade C+ (very promising, want more data)
10. Angel Salome, C, Grade C+
11. Michael Brantley, OF, Grade C+ (a personal favorite I admit)
12. Lorenzo Cain, OF, Grade C+
13. Zach Braddock, LHP, Grade C+
14. Robert Bryson, RHP, Grade C+
15. Hernan Iribarren, 2B, Grade C+
16. Brent Brewer, SS, Grade C (yes I know all about his tools. He is so damn raw that I don't believe in him yet.)
17. R.J. Seidel, RHP, Grade C
18. Zack Jackson, LHP, Grade C
19. Cody Scarpetta, RHP, Grade C
20. Dan Merklinger, LHP, Grade C
“This system has been thinned out by promotions and trades, but I suspect they will recharge quickly.”For fear of this post getting too long, I will provide what I believe to be the Brewers’ Top-10, along with a percentage grade out of 100% - like you’d see in school or in MVP Baseball - rather than a letter grade like Sickels uses. I will post more, including individual player evals, in the comments.
1) Matt LaPorta – 91%
2) Manny Parra – 89%
3) Jeremy Jeffress – 80%
4) Mat Gamel – 79%
5) Robert Bryson – 78%
6) Cole Gillespie – 75%
7) Zach Braddock – 73%
8) Taylor Green – 70%
9) Angel Salome – 68%
10) Michael Brantley – 68%
Labels: Brewers Prospects