Most overrated players in baseball
I'm supposed to be studying, so obviously I'm spending as much time reading about baseball as I am reading about cost accounting. Plus also, it's an off day and there's no Brewers game to talk about, just our Pirates. So . . . who do you feel are the most overrated players in baseball? The reason I ask is because for about the fourth time today, somebody referred to Ervin Santana as though he's supposed to be some kind of uber-valuable wonderkind of a pitcher, yet he's had one year with an ERA+ over 100, and it was only 102. He reeks of league average and nothing more. Off the cuff, here are a few others I find overrated:
Miguel Tejada (now)
Mike Mussina (now)
Obviously, I've omitted the traditional Eckstein and Erstad type players from the conversation and tried to find players undeserving of their relatively lofty 'big name' status. Of those listed, I find Baldelli the most overrated ofensive player and Santana the most overrated pitcher. Your thoughts?